Did anybody follow......

[anne]

Dancing with the Stars? Go ahead, admit it.......I know that *I* did not alone make it the #2 show Tuesday night.

Anyway, for anyone who did follow, what did you think? As semi-part-time past professional, I'm curious to hear what the rest of the world thought.

 

[Tman122]

It's been cloudy here. And I don't like to dance outside anyway when it's cold out.  

 

[East_TX_Spa]

Unless Shabba-Doo and Boogaloo Shrimp were contestants, it has no street cred.

Termiloo Crawdaddy

 

[lets]

What's Dancing with the Stars? Sounds kind of native American.

 

[tanstaafl2]

Never fear, in spite of what the forum comedians have to say you are not alone. My girlfriend and I watched the original series on a lark during the slow summer season and have been hooked ever since. But while I watch the show I have never taken time to vote for anybody. And probably never will.


Some people I work with felt that Lopez was a trained dancer, so they rooted for Smith, who worked harder and had more to learn. This may have been the big difference in the end as I think many felt this way. I was happy with Smith as the winner but wouldn't have been disappointed either way. Although I don't know that Lopez was a "trained" dancer, he clearly had more dance training than probably any one else coming in this season and was probably similar to Stacy Kiebler last season (In fact she probably had had more formal training the Lopez prior to her participation in the show.) Like many actors he probably had some dance training when younger, he says he has had tap and "hip hop" dance lessons but never any formal ballroom lessons. Hard to know what the truth is for sure. Not that it mattered that much to me. Indeed Kiebler placed third and he was second so maybe looking too good at the start proves to be a tough obstacle to overcome!

As result Smith to me made the the most dramatic improvement over the course of the show. He clearly never equaled Lopez in technical skill, indeed he may not have been as "technically" good at the end as Lopez was at the beginning. But his charm and appeal may have attracted more voters because Lopez seemed more like a pro to begin with.

But what do I know, I have two right feet!

 

[East_TX_Spa]

I was happy with Smith as the winner but wouldn't have been disappointed either way.

IF you are referring to the nefarious Dr. Zachary Smith, I could certainly understand how he would be the popular choice.  He is a graceful man.

However, he ain't no Boogaloo Shrimp.  Shabba-Doo, MC Hammer, or even Bobby Brown would wipe the floor with that ol' geezer!

MC Termy

 

[Spatech_tuo]

1) I somehow forgot to watch. :

2) Barry Sanders, Jim Brown, Walter P and LT would have done much better.

 

[East_TX_Spa]

Peg Leg Bates could pirouette like no man before or since.

Couldn't no one hang with Peg Leg, lest they were doing a polka.  He sucked at polkas.

Three-Legged Term

 

[lets]

I seriously don't get.... And they canceled Enterprise?

 

[anne]

I seriously don't get.... And they canceled Enterprise?

huh?

 

[anne]

OK, there are a few people here who need to be more open minded! If Emmit Smith can get out there and give dancing a good name, then ya'll should give it a chance.

tanstaafl2, I think you are right that Mario downplayed his *level* of hip hop experience, and he probably does martial arts, based on his flexibility. But I really dont think he had latin or ballroom expereince going into this. In the beginning, he looked really good, but still did some beginnerish things that someone with a little training would not do (little technical things that most people would not care about.) I sort of think that Mario should have won, as he was technically better, but I do think that Emmit made the longer journey of improvement and had a style to his dancing that transcends technique. And Emmit winning does more for dancing as a sport (to me) than Mario winning.

 

 

[pg_rider]

So You Think You Can Dance > Dancing With The Stars



Seriously, So You Think You Can Dance is awesome entertainment.  Can't wait til next season!  Anne, did you watch it?  What did you think?

 

[anne]

So You Think You Can Dance > Dancing With The Stars



Seriously, So You Think You Can Dance is awesome entertainment.  Can't wait til next season!  Anne, did you watch it?  What did you think?

Dancing with the stars is just weak entertainment to keep me going until the next So You Think You can Dance. I LOVE that show. OK, anyone out there shaking their head and thinking "what a weanie show" has to WATCH it before passing any judgement. And then if you are still rolling your eyes, I 'll dare you to take one waltz or hip hop class and still not be impressed by them.......I do like th stars show for the fact that it shows that anyone can do it. But for actually impressive entertainment, "so you think..." is awesome.