Hot springs vs bullfrog vs jacuzzi vs Maax

[Spatech_tuo]

Interesting. They make a big deal about their energy efficiency and insulation. They show a chart in which they exceed energy efficiency standards in CAlifornia and compare their bigger spa with other brand spas and it is more efficient. Also they say repair technicians don't have to deal with digging through foam. $8900 seemed a fair price. Am I paying too much?

I'm not sure those efficiency standards are that tough to meet. Every spa brand makes a big deal out of how well their spa is insulated including those that really are and those that actually aren't.

Here's a chart they like to use to say how efficient they are

http://www.allaboutspas.com/How-Much-Does-it-Cost-to-Run-a-Hot-Tub-s/26252.htm

What a bogus chart. Random spas.  Grandee listed twice with different dimensions and cost.
These numbers are for "stand by mode".  This is assuming you do not use the spa.  It is just maintaining heat with the cover on.

I also love how they list jet count which is as meaningful to energy usage as # of cup holders vs maybe listing something relative to pump info.

[Jacuzzi Jim]

  That insulation product is the same stuff Jacuzzi/Sundance uses in their smart seal option.    It's basically recycled jean material. 

[Sam]

Lol the grandee has 100 more gallons than the maax.  Nice comparison 


I really hate deceptive marketing.  The maax guys are known for being dishonest.  Ask any road show veteran.  They'll all tell you the same thing.

[Hottubguy]

Lol the grandee has 100 more gallons than the maax.  Nice comparison 


I really hate deceptive marketing.  The maax guys are known for being dishonest.  Ask any road show veteran.  They'll all tell you the same thing.

They tell customers anything they want to here.  I just went against them in a home show a few weeks ago.  Couldn't believe some of the crap coming out of there mouths.  In my opion the tub isn't bad but it doesn't compete with a bullfrog, marquis, hot spring, caldera, sundance or jacuzzi

[Tman122]

I find MAXX lacking on insulation, which equates to energy hungry. Seems the noise level ends up high because of this also. Their equipment area laid out sloppily. The fit and finish of the cabinet and components sloppy.

But maybe the wet test says it is the tub for you.

Generally less expensive construction can lead to lower prices. Not to say that a lessor life expectancy is necessarily less value. Parts can be easy to find at good prices and changing out parts isn't that hard. Less insulation means easier to work on, maybe that's important to you? You have 4 good choices in front of you. See which is comfortable on your back side first then start looking at construction.

It seems to me that easy to work on means less time being repaired if something goes wrong. Of course, not needing repairs is even better.

In my area I could only wet test the Maax and hot springs envoy. Maax was definitely better in fit and ability to individually control jets. Also the lounge chair was much better since my wife didn't float away. I'd love to wet test the bullfrog or jacuzzi but can't. Is $8900 to much to pay for the Maax? What would be fair? Or are you saying I could get better for the money?

Sorry blueandwhite for riling the guys up but a lot of what they are saying has been said in the past. The spa's, not bad but not good either. The company..............well, you hear some good out of them but they've been passed around a few times? Do your own looking inside and pass on the sales pitches for now. 8900 is to much for that tub.

[Hottubguy]

I find MAXX lacking on insulation, which equates to energy hungry. Seems the noise level ends up high because of this also. Their equipment area laid out sloppily. The fit and finish of the cabinet and components sloppy.

But maybe the wet test says it is the tub for you.

Generally less expensive construction can lead to lower prices. Not to say that a lessor life expectancy is necessarily less value. Parts can be easy to find at good prices and changing out parts isn't that hard. Less insulation means easier to work on, maybe that's important to you? You have 4 good choices in front of you. See which is comfortable on your back side first then start looking at construction.

It seems to me that easy to work on means less time being repaired if something goes wrong. Of course, not needing repairs is even better.

In my area I could only wet test the Maax and hot springs envoy. Maax was definitely better in fit and ability to individually control jets. Also the lounge chair was much better since my wife didn't float away. I'd love to wet test the bullfrog or jacuzzi but can't. Is $8900 to much to pay for the Maax? What would be fair? Or are you saying I could get better for the money?

Sorry blueandwhite for riling the guys up but a lot of what they are saying has been said in the past. The spa's, not bad but not good either. The company..............well, you hear some good out of them but they've been passed around a few times? Do your own looking inside and pass on the sales pitches for now. 8900 is to much for that tub.

+1. You can get much more hot tub for 9k

[Blueandwhite]

Thanks again for all the responses. Can I ask what would you consider a fair price for a Maax 471? Or what other tub could I get for a similar price?

[Hottubguy]

Thanks again for all the responses. Can I ask what would you consider a fair price for a Maax 471? Or what other tub could I get for a similar price?

I'm not really sure wholesale pricing on those tubs.  If you think you are getting a good deal and are happy with the tub then maybe it's your best option.  Are their any other dealers nearby that you havent mentioned?  Maybe marquis, caldera or dimension one?

[Blueandwhite]

The same dealer sells jacuzzis. Otherwise it's hot springs or bullfrog. I live in a small town. The jacuzzi seemed nice but couldn't wet test it.

[Hottubguy]

He wouldn't fill a jacuzzi for you. The 300 series should be priced about the same?  That doesn't make a ton of sense that he would only fill a maax. Is the deal on a floor model?

[Blueandwhite]

He actually had none to wet test. We had to drive 1 1/2 hours to wet test it. They both had similar pricing. So a jacuzzi 300 is a better tub at that price? Anything specific about the jacuzzi?

[Hottubguy]

I think they are better built, more energy efficient and more therapeutic. Again that's my opinion. I don't think maax makes a bad tub just to me I wouldn't spend that amount of money on one. It's too bad you couldn't wet test more brands. Is the dealer you are looking at a bigger dealer, how long has he sold maax and does he service them?

[MarKee]

A funny thing I noticed on the diagram that shows the cross-section of a MAAX spa.  It shows the back side of a few jets with clamped plumbing connections.  MAAX does not use any clamped connections on the plumbing.

[BullFrogSpasMN]

The same dealer sells jacuzzis. Otherwise it's hot springs or bullfrog. I live in a small town. The jacuzzi seemed nice but couldn't wet test it.

Do you have the ability to wet test the Bullfrog R7/A7 locally?

[Tman122]

Why have you crossed off HS or BF? Seems to me both those brands should have similar tubs in that price range or close. They will be quality built and last a long time.

Look for yourself. You will see it. Don't be wowed by lights and moving water. Or energy use claims and sales pitches. You will be the only one who can see a quality difference, fit and finish.

Look at the cabinet and shell and how the two meet on the top and how the cabinet meets the base on the bottom. Tell him to turn the jets off. See how the jets mate to the shell surface there's a lot of ways to do these, so check it out closely. Is it going to be comfortable?

See how the controls are laid out and how solid they look/feel.

Is it comfortable to step up, sit on the edge, does it feel solid? Spin around and get into the bottom of the tub. How easy was it? Stand on the bottom and bounce a bit, it's not yours. Is it solid or bouncy? Are the seats the right height so it's easy to turn and sit anywhere, not to low, not to high. Easy to get up?

You can get a lot of this for 8-10gs

Feel free to print this to bring to the store.

Forgot, listen to it. Louder than you expected or quieter?