I agree with you on Manning and Palmer. I think Eli Manning will be an outstanding QB. I think Roethlisberger, McNabb, and Vick are overrated. Vick's a great athlete but doesn't throw the ball downfield as well as he should. Drew Brees is streaky, but I think he will play for many years at a high level. I think Alex Smith is going to be Joey Harrington in a couple of years. Not sold on Chris Simms or Rex Grossman or Ken Dorsey. Local McNown boy from East Texas will probably always be a backup.
Orton in Chicago may turn out to be a good one. David Carr will never be more than mediocre.
Oh, if I had to pick one to start a team right now, it'd be Tom Brady or Carson Palmer.
Terminator