IMO opinion both are reputable tubs with lots of satisfied customers. I think you are hearing the dreaded "salesguy talks down the competition mode" that really turns me off as a buyer. I've owned two tubs, one with and one without a circ pump. Its not my highest priority in choosing. I've been in both of those tubs and I recommend you go with the one that is most comfortable for you to use, you get a better deal on, and the dealer that makes you the most comfortable, or some factor of these three.