Welcome to our forum.
No I dont think it would, the only downfall of the spa brella is I am not sure I would want to screw the base to the side of the spa, it does slide under but I really dont know how it would hold up to high wind,but then you cant really use it in high wind anyway.
Nice setup Richs100! Do you remember how much you paid for the HS umbrella? Trying to get an idea of how much a good umbrella costs.
I'm pretty sure I found the exact same one as Rich's for $299 at one of the links in my previous post. Looks like the one to me, what do you think?