Hi! Welcome to the wonderful world of hot tubs. There are many great spas out there. I would keep on looking until you find the tub you really like. I don't know much about the spas you mentioned, but tubs made by Marquis, Bullfrog, Sundance, Artic, Hot Springs, etc., are well made and have many satisfied owners. They also support their products with top notch warranties. Take your time and continue your reseach!